13 Comments

I read somewhere the phrase "covid is a social construct".

The pandemic can be ended tomorrow. All it would take is political will, firing a couple of people, and a change in messaging and narrative. I consider this the defining moral imperative of our time

Expand full comment
founding
Jan 25, 2022·edited Jan 25, 2022

"Even if we all agree that it would be desirable to “get covid under control” or “end the pandemic,” we don’t actually agree on what real-world situations these words describe." -- this is because no credible conversation with anybody other than a few "medical experts"--and we see how expert they are have been-- has been allowed without smashing non-conforming (to bureaucrats) views and reasoned alternatives. That's the problem, we all agree words mean something, but we haven't even been able to "have words." Our allowed discursive interpretations have been tyrannically forced upon us.

Expand full comment
Jan 25, 2022·edited Jan 25, 2022

Great thoughts from this linguist. Hesitating to share it ... everytime I post anything other then Covid-Zero stuff I am attacked by an army of Covidians who tell me that there are no more lockdowns or closures and that the kids are just fine. I had several people using the same exact phrases telling me that thanks to me people were dying, that I was selfishly infecting people? (for saying some restrictions were excessive), on and on I'm a Trumpist anti-vaxxer for pointing out that my child suffered during the school closures. Not sure maybe bots but the hate was really over the top! We need better leadership messaging, for sure.

Expand full comment
founding
Jan 25, 2022·edited Jan 26, 2022

I guess I want to say that the Biden administration should NOT get to redefine terms after using provisional definitions to win an election, continuing a tragic public policy of supporting tragic mitigation measures that really hurt an entire generation, weakening not strengthening almost every aspect of society and likely break the economic back of our country, all the while smiling a doppy smile. And then saying they won by changing the definitions that we clearly know they were not operating under.

The linguistic twists ??

Covid death: "With covid" vs "from covid"

"Vaccine": (Helper or conqueror?--we just all learned it's a helper)

"Gain of function": no such thing, it's a term we made up that doesn't mean anything- ala F.Collins.

"Herd Immunity": dirty word until you have it, then it's a blessing.

Expand full comment

This is wonderful! But, alas, it is preaching to the choir, and those who really need to hear it will not be listening.

Expand full comment
Jan 25, 2022·edited Jan 25, 2022

"they think that they agree on a shared goal when they actually envision drastically different realities"

This describes every group project in the history of the world - work, school, home improvement, vacation planning, divisive social movements, SCOTUS decisions, etc.

It's nothing new. Presidential campaign slogans and promises have a long history of being meaningless. How, exactly, does one "Build Back Better" or "Make America Great Again" or create "Change We Can Believe In"? A president can't be held accountable for keeping or breaking their promises if their results are unmeasurable.

The pandemic response in the US may have been less harmful both socially and medically if politicians hadn't said a word about it and left mitigation as personal conversations between people and their physicians.

Expand full comment
Jan 28, 2022·edited Jan 28, 2022

Unfortunately, the political and social precedents set by the covid pandemic will allow future diseases to be used as a tool, much like the War on Terror, the War on Drugs, homeless crisis, etc. are used for political aims or power grabs.

I really, really, really hope flu season isn't used as an excuse for shutting schools down or mandating vaccines.

Dr. Prasad, I also liked your recent video about people are talking about the pandemic as if it "caused" schools to shut down, businesses to close, etc. From the very beginning (March 2020), I was telling people that Covid isn't causing anything, it's human and government decisions. Whether those decisions were justified or not, we still have to acknowledge that the virus/pandemic itself isn't causing these mandates to be enacted. I think saying things like "schools are closed due to covid" is a way of shifting the blame. Rain doesn't force you to stay home instead of driving to the gym for a much-needed workout. Unless there's a thunderstorm that puts your life in danger on the road, you've made a decision not to go the gym, although bad weather might have nudged you in that direction. However, you must recognize that the decision is still yours. Otherwise, you are admitting you are without agency.

Anyway, a bit of a ramble, but I hope that all makes sense. Very frustrating and worrying times, indeed.

Expand full comment

I love this….

Expand full comment

I work at UC Berkeley campus and I am being required to obtain a vaccine + booster and submit proof. This just astounds me... I have to choose between my morals and providing for my family. I am a healthy 38 year old. I am <10% body fat and have my nutriion dialed in. I am in NO danger of this disease and should not be REQUIRED to obtain a vaccine/booster because others. It is also an enigma that this vaccine (per the CDC) does not protect you from contracting or spreading the virus... what is the point?

I am at a loss of what I can do to fight this... is it really down to get the vaccine or be fired?? Is there nothing I can do?

Expand full comment